Stormwater Management

Overview

Stormwater is defined as surface water that concentrates as a result of precipitation, in locations where water is generally not otherwise found. Stormwater is created when precipitation does not infiltrate the ground, as a result of one or more conditions:

  1. Precipitation falls onto an impervious or semi-permeable surface (including both natural and constructed surfaces).
  2. Precipitation falls onto a soil or other material that is already saturated.
  3. Precipitation accumulates at a rate that exceeds the infiltration capacity of the soil it is falling onto.

Concentrated and channelized stormwater is usually referred to as runoff, but the two terms are used interchangeably. Stormwater can also include runoff resulting from snowmelt.

Almost everything we do on the ground has an effect on the way water interacts with the earth’s surface. The most dramatic and obvious impacts result from constructing buildings, installing pavement, or making a surface impervious to water in some other way (meaning no water can infiltrate, or soak into the soil). In these cases all of the precipitation that falls becomes stormwater. But there are other ways our activities can generate stormwater and runoff. The compaction of soil, whether by traffic, equipment, or trampling by people or animals, or resulting from the removal of vegetation, makes soil less permeable – it reduces both the rate at which water can infiltrate the soil, and the total amount of moisture a soil can hold. Precipitation falling on a compacted soil can infiltrate that soil as long as it is not already saturated with water, or if the rate at which rain falls doesn’t exceed the rate at which the soil can absorb it. Once either of these conditions exists, stormwater is generated.

Stormwater Impacts

When stormwater is allowed to run off, it typically finds its way to a stream or other water body via the most direct, downhill route, and can cause a number of damaging impacts. Among these are erosion in the form of rilling and gullying; elevated streamflows caused by the rapid routing of runoff to stream channels, which causes additional erosion of the stream bed and banks; degradation of both water quality and aquatic habitat as sediment is mobilized; lowered groundwater levels, as less water infiltrates the soil and as the stream incises; and decreasing dry season streamflows. In addition to these direct impacts, excessive runoff of stormwater also results in a multitude of indirect impacts, further degrading water resources and aquatic habitat. These are discussed in greater detail below.

[back to top]

Water Savings

There are three important numbers to calculate when considering a stormwater retention project, and each of these numbers plays a role in determining how much water you will save by implementing a project.

  1. Water demand: How much water do you want to capture, or does your operation require? This can be a year-round estimate, or it can be for the dry season only.
  2. Collection capacity: How much water that currently runs off as stormwater can be captured and stored? This number is dependent on two factors: the catchment surface area and the annual rainfall. Since rainfall varies from year to year, it is a good idea to plan your system to function fully in a drought year.
  3. Storage capacity: How much space for storage exists on your site, and what are your cost limitations? Storage is generally the most expensive component of a rainwater catchment or stormwater retention system, and costs vary depending on a number of factors. In general, water storage can consist of either water tanks or ponds or both.

Every gallon of water captured and stored during the rainy season is a gallon that will not have to be extracted, purchased or otherwise acquired during the dry season. There is usually a compromise to be made between desired volume, space requirements and costs for water storage, and collection capacity.

[back to top]

Applications

There are a number of proven strategies for effectively dealing with stormwater and runoff. These fall into three broad categories: stormwater dispersion, stormwater retention and infiltration, and stormwater retention and storage. The first two will work to locally recharge groundwater aquifers and alleviate the impacts of uncontrolled stormwater runoff, but will not result in any savings for water users. The retention and storage of stormwater has water supply impacts that can be directly quantified and put through a cost-benefits analysis.

Stormwater dispersion and infiltration

Keeping stormwater dispersed is perhaps the easiest and most cost-effective way of preventing the impacts that come from runoff. This approach essentially mimics natural conditions by dispersing stormwater over a large area, promoting infiltration, and is easier and less expensive to achieve if the stormwater is not allowed to concentrate in the first place.

For dispersion and infiltration to work, the infiltration surface should not be compacted. Dispersing runoff over compacted soil may still be successful in infiltrating the water, but during heavier rains the infiltration capacity of the soil may be exceeded. For compacted soil surfaces, decompaction may be the only treatment needed to eliminate stormwater and runoff, since it improves the infiltration capacity of the soil. Decompaction of soils can be done quickly using mechanical means such as hydraulic ripping or tilling, or can be achieved through the establishment of vegetation. As plants grow, their roots are very effective at decompacting soil, but it can take years for the soil to recover its permeability. Intentional incorporation of appropriate organic materials such as chipped woody debris or stabilized compost in some soil types can accelerate improved infiltration, permeability, and retention, and also assist in reducing erosion. All methods of dispersion and infiltration must be designed to accommodate the maximum intensity of rainfall that can be expected for the location.

    • Dispersed drainage: The most simple and straightforward way to reduce or eliminate the impacts of stormwater runoff is to disperse it at the point where it is generated. In practical terms this means to drain impervious or compacted surfaces in a dispersed manner. For structures, this might involve removing rain gutters and allowing stormwater to flow evenly off all sides of a building. This allows the water to be dispersed to the maximum extent possible directly from the roof. In cases where water needs to be kept away from a building’s foundation, dispersion of stormwater involves the installation of multiple downspouts along rain gutters. The greater the number of downspouts, the more dispersed the runoff will be. The water can be conveyed away from the downspouts via pipes, but it is important that water from multiple downspouts not be combined or channeled into a single pipe or ditch, since this concentrates the runoff and increases its potential to cause erosion and negative impacts. Stormwater can also be conveyed away from a structure in perforated pipe, allowing the water to meter out of the pipe in small quantities at many locations. For structures associated with livestock, dispersing drainage must be carefully planned and executed to avoid unintended impacts to water quality during high intensity rainfall events. For paved areas, stormwater dispersion involves crowning or outsloping the paved surface, so that stormwater drains from as many sides as possible. If possible, paved areas should not have curbs, which concentrate stormwater. If curbs are necessary for safety, they should have multiple breaks or gaps to allow for the maximum possible dispersion of water. Stormwater dispersion from paved areas is most effective if the necessary grading and sloping are included in the original design. With any of these methods, the goal is to spread out the runoff, minimizing the amount of water conveyed to the ground at any single location.
    • Keyline design describes a suite of practices designed to use water more efficiently, and includes methods to improve soil permeability and soil water storage while causing minimal disturbance to the soil and vegetation. Keyline plowing discourages the generation of runoff by allowing sheet flow to more effectively infiltrate the soil.

Stormwater retention and infiltration

Stormwater can be retained for infiltration into the ground by conveying it to a location that has been specifically designed to allow water to sink into the soil over time. In this case, the primary goals are to minimize the ecological and property damage that result from the uncontrolled runoff, and to locally recharge the groundwater table. This approach is highly effective in recharging groundwater but is less practical for agricultural operations, as it can require substantial space and infrastructure development, and the potential benefits to water supply are indirect and difficult to measure.

  • Retention basins
  • Swales or bioswales: Stormwater can be conveyed away from a building or other impervious or compacted surface via pipes or low gradient ditches to a vegetated, low-gradient swale, or bioswales.

An important component of both of these methods is an adequate overflow. When stormwater is retained it is necessarily concentrated in a limited space. Should the amount of stormwater exceed the space available for infiltration, the excess water must be conveyed away from the area without causing erosion. Generally this conveyance leads to a stream or other water body, reducing the benefit of stormwater retention. However, a properly designed retention basin, swale, or other retention structure should experience overflow only rarely, when a heavy rainfall occurs during saturated conditions.

Stormwater retention and storage

Stormwater retention and storage involves collecting stormwater and storing it for future use. This practice reduces damage from uncontrolled runoff and provides water supply flexibility, reducing long-term water costs. It is appropriate in most parts of California, where water is limited, where precipitation is seasonal or infrequent, or where chronic water shortages exist.

  • Ponds: Agricultural ponds for water supply are relatively common. Ponds reduce the generation of stormwater by directly collecting rainfall, and in most cases are constructed to collect stormwater as sheetflow, before it has become channelized. Ponds can also be used to collect and store stormwater that is generated by agricultural drainage systems, such as vineyard drainage tiles, and from impervious surfaces such as roofs and paved areas (see “rainwater harvesting” below). Ponds do not require appropriative water rights in California as long as they do not collect water from a natural channel – sheetflow and runoff from agricultural drainage systems are not within the purview of the State Water Resources Control Board.
  • Rainwater harvesting: Construction of rainwater harvesting systems on a variety of scales is becoming more popular in California. Most of the state has a Mediterranean climate with distinct wet and dry seasons, and the benefits of capturing and storing rainfall (before it becomes stormwater) are becoming more widely recognized. In the wet season, stormwater is generated when it rains, and in most cases this water runs off, causing erosion and depleting groundwater. During the dry season, water is in high demand but is scarce, so it is extracted from streams or groundwater, imported, etc., resulting in ecological damage, groundwater depletion and economic loss and inefficiency. Rainwater harvesting collects water that would otherwise run off from roofs or other impervious surfaces and stores it for future use, simultaneously addressing the problems of water scarcity and stormwater impacts. The only things necessary to harvest rainwater are a surface to collect water from and a place to store it.

[back to top]

Additional Benefits

As noted above, when stormwater is allowed to concentrate and run off in an uncontrolled manner, a number of detrimental impacts follow. The implementation of any of the strategies outlined above will work to limit or eliminate these impacts.

When stormwater is allowed to run off, it typically finds its way to a stream or other water body via the most direct, downhill route, and can cause a number of damaging impacts.

    • Erosion: The most straightforward and observable impacts is erosion. The channelized flow of runoff over a surface that is not adjusted to it causes erosion in the form of rilling and gullying, which have a number of damaging effects. Gullying causes the degradation and loss of soil, which reduces the area of usable land and can impact soil fertility. Gullying that results from uncontrolled stormwater runoff causes millions of dollars in property damage throughout the world each year. The soil that is eroded by runoff is usually transported to a stream or other water body, causing a number of harmful effects, including decreased water quality.
    • Impacts to surface hydrology: The addition of runoff to the existing network of stream channels has multiple impacts to surface hydrology. Unlike water that infiltrates the soil, runoff makes its way to a stream very rapidly, elevating peak streamflows, increasing the erosive power of the stream and causing in-channel erosion. This erosion typically occurs as stream channel incision, where the stream erodes and deepens its bed, and as channel widening. Incision of a stream can cause local drops in the water table, which means that less groundwater is stored in the soil (see below). Stream widening usually occurs through bank failure, where the stream undercuts and erodes its banks. Widening can lead to the loss of riparian vegetation, degrading wildlife habitat and impacting water quality.
    • Water quality: Stormwater that is allowed to run off into a stream or other water body degrades surface water quality in a number of ways. Runoff will transport contaminants that it encounters along the way, as well as sediment that is created through soil erosion. Runoff from paved surfaces can pick up oils and other substances that originate with motor vehicles, and runoff from agricultural facilities or pasture land with compacted soil can transport nitrogen compounds and other contaminants that originate in animal manure and urine, as well as pesticides, herbicides and other potentially harmful chemicals. Runoff may also degrade water quality by raising the temperature of the water body it enters.
    • Aquatic habitat: All of these stormwater impacts degrade the quality of habitat for aquatic organisms, including fish, amphibians and invertebrates. A large variety of organisms are highly sensitive to contaminants, many of which can cause health and reproduction problems. Excess fine sediment delivered to lakes and streams by gullying and instream erosion can smother fish and amphibians and their eggs, as well as invertebrates that live in the gravels on the bottom.
    • Groundwater: A less obvious stormwater impact is its effect on groundwater. Precipitation that infiltrates the soil is stored as groundwater. Like surface water, groundwater moves downhill through the soil toward streams and lakes. Unlike surface water, groundwater movement is extremely slow– where surface runoff can flow into a stream or lake in a matter of minutes or hours, groundwater may take weeks, months or even years to reach a surface water body. This slow movement allows groundwater to contribute to streamflow during times of dry weather or drought. This “baseflow” is reduced if more precipitation is converted into stormwater and runoff, and less water is allowed to infiltrate the soil. Where a stream has become incised due to elevated peak flows, the lowered “base level” of the stream causes water in the soil to drain out more quickly than it would in the absence of incision. All of these conditions result in less groundwater, reducing the amount of water available both to provide baseflow in streams, and for extraction through wells.

[back to top]

Resources

Rainwater as a Resource: An On-Farm Guide
Produced by the UK Environment Agency, this comprehensive publication includes rainwater harvesting systems, case studies and harvesting information for different agricultural sectors.

American Rainwater Catchment Systems Association
The American Rainwater Catchment Systems Association is a 501©(3) non-profit organization that was founded in 1994 by Dr. Hari J. Krishna in Austin, Texas, to promote rainwater catchment systems in the United States. Membership consists of professionals working in city, state, and federal government, academia, manufacturers and suppliers of rainwater harvesting equipment, consultants, and other interested individuals.

Slow it. Spread it. Sink it! A homeowner’s and Landowner’s Guide to Beneficial Stormwater Management
The guidebook helps landowners and homeowners make the most of the many potential benefits of innovative storm water management. Once thought of as a nuisance, storm water is now universally recognized as one our most important natural resources and proper management (simple to complex) is more important than ever.

Rainwater Harvesting for Drylands and Beyond
Brad Lancaster is a well-known teacher, author, and practitioner of rainwater harvesting. His website includes practical information and links to videos, books, and many other resources.

Water Wise: Rainwater Harvesting
The University of Arizona Cooperative Extension of Cochise County Water Wise Program includes practical information on water harvesting.

[back to top]

Case Studies

Hedgerow Farms

John Anderson, the founder of Hedgerow Farms was driven to become a farmer because his love of wildlife and concern about disappearing wildlife habitats. Hedgerow Farms grows over 60 species of native grassland seed and transplants for various bioregional eco-types. Filter strips/buffers in these vegetated systems capture and prevent sediment, nutrients, and pesticides from entering waterways and groundwater.

Integrated Stormwater Retention System

This Occidental Arts and Ecology Center case study demonstrates innovative stormwater management solutions for rural landowners. The primary design goals of the project were to improve water quantity through increased well water production and improve water quality of a nearby salmonid bearing creek.

Rainwater Catchment at Brookside Farms in Willits, CA

A video produced as part of the City of Willits Water Conservation Project covering a 1-acre organic fruit and vegetable farm.

Harley Farms Goat Dairy

This video is part of the Water Stewardship video series produced by the Ecological Farming Association. Harley Farms Goat Dairy captures and recycles rainwater as well as water from the dairy and creamery. These efforts save 40,000 gallons of water per year and allow for the development of specialty crop production for on-farm dinners.

Rainfall Capture and Storage for Marin Agriculture

This publication by UCANR presents rainwater capture and storage as a promising option for developing additional agricultural water sources. The Marin Countywide Plan contains policies and programs that demonstrate County government’s support for exploration and development of small-scale alternative water sources for agriculture. Collection and storage of direct rainfall or upland sheet flow may in some cases be a viable alternative to the historic tradition of capturing and storing water that flows within a natural channel, a practice that is now highly regulated and for which it is difficult to obtain water rights.

Planting Justice

This case study explores various water-efficient practices associated with urban agriculture, and highlights Planting Justice, an organization that incorporates principles of small-scale, sustainable food production with food justice and economic justice efforts.

Oaklands Farm

Produced by Farming Futures, UK, this video covers the catchment system and set up on a chicken farm which saves 100,000 British pounds per year in water rates.

Bodega Valley Rainwater Catchment & Alternative Water Supply Program

This case study looks at the roof water harvest, off-channel ponds, and storage tanks used by farmers, private homeowners, and the Bodega Bay Volunteer Fire Department. Together in a community based program, these groups are using roof water harvesting systems for alternative water supply during the summer months, reducing the need to divert water from streams for agricultural and community needs.

[back to top]

Page Credit

Content for this page was originally developed by John Green, Gold Ridge Resource Conservation District with help from Valerie Minton, Sonoma Resource Conservation District. Various others have since contributed content.